- Joined
- Feb 4, 2022
- Messages
- 2,772
- Reaction score
- 1,993
Compare this to airstrikes in Gaza which tend to leave a much larger crater and cause a lot more damage, they also almost always leave big deposits of concrete dust after striking a structure, though the construction of this particular hospital could be different.
I spent a while looking for an individual IAF airstrike on a singular structure, rather than broad/widespread devestation, and found this in lower resolution imagery. It shows the crater, but also the concrete dust cloud deposits that are around 30m from the impact site.
Also see this to show the scale of the structural damage and concrete dust.
Looking at the ratio between red and infrared bands shows a better view of the actual impacts through the smoke and concrete dust. This is Beit Hanoun near the Erez crossing. Absolutely unprecedented levels of bombardment, including of civilian
Next I want to address the claimed casualty count of 500+ killed, which seems widely inconsistent with the damage we can see. I am not doubting that civilians were killed, videos show the bodies collected in the hospital courtyard and I have no reason to doubt that.
It is also more than possible that there were many people in the area. And the casualties could be quite high, especially if people were out in the open and there was falling, burning fuel.
But 500's incredibly high number, honestly implausible. Overlaying the area of damage on Google Earth - keep in mind this is mostly from burning cars NOT the explosion - it is 228m2. This is that sort of crowd density (assuming there were no survivors which is also implausible).
In July 2016 a truck bomb in Baghdad killed ~350, this is the damage it did. In Oct 2017, a truck bomb in Mogadishu killed 500+, this is the damage it did. In Oct 2022, a truck bomb in Mogadishu killed ~125, this is the damage it did. Compare any of that to the above.
Full Credit to - https://twitter.com/Nrg8000
I spent a while looking for an individual IAF airstrike on a singular structure, rather than broad/widespread devestation, and found this in lower resolution imagery. It shows the crater, but also the concrete dust cloud deposits that are around 30m from the impact site.
Also see this to show the scale of the structural damage and concrete dust.
Looking at the ratio between red and infrared bands shows a better view of the actual impacts through the smoke and concrete dust. This is Beit Hanoun near the Erez crossing. Absolutely unprecedented levels of bombardment, including of civilian
Next I want to address the claimed casualty count of 500+ killed, which seems widely inconsistent with the damage we can see. I am not doubting that civilians were killed, videos show the bodies collected in the hospital courtyard and I have no reason to doubt that.
It is also more than possible that there were many people in the area. And the casualties could be quite high, especially if people were out in the open and there was falling, burning fuel.
But 500's incredibly high number, honestly implausible. Overlaying the area of damage on Google Earth - keep in mind this is mostly from burning cars NOT the explosion - it is 228m2. This is that sort of crowd density (assuming there were no survivors which is also implausible).
In July 2016 a truck bomb in Baghdad killed ~350, this is the damage it did. In Oct 2017, a truck bomb in Mogadishu killed 500+, this is the damage it did. In Oct 2022, a truck bomb in Mogadishu killed ~125, this is the damage it did. Compare any of that to the above.
Full Credit to - https://twitter.com/Nrg8000